Consolidating Debt in Canada: Is It a Good Idea

Debt consolidation Canada is a common strategy Canadians consider to simplify payments and lower interest on multiple debts. If you're looking to consolidate credit card debt or pursue loan consolidation, this guide explains the options, pros and cons, steps to take, and where to get reliable Canadian help.

Credit & BorrowingIntermediate
Read time:4 minUpdated: Sep 06, 2025

Debt consolidation Canada is a common strategy Canadians consider to simplify payments and lower interest on multiple debts. If you're looking to consolidate credit card debt or pursue loan consolidation, this guide explains the options, pros and cons, steps to take, and where to get reliable Canadian help.

What is debt consolidation?

  • Definition: Debt consolidation combines two or more debts into a single loan or payment arrangement. It doesn't erase what you owe; it reorganizes it.

  • Common methods: unsecured personal loans, balance transfer credit cards, chequing account overdraft conversions, home equity lines of credit (HELOC), mortgage refinancing, consumer proposals, and debt management plans.


Quick comparison of common options

  • Unsecured debt consolidation loan

    • Pros: Fixed payment, predictable end date, no collateral required.

    • Cons: Interest depends on credit score; may not lower rate enough.

  • Balance transfer credit card

    • Pros: 0% or low introductory rate can save interest if repaid quickly.

    • Cons: High rate after intro period; balance transfer fees; credit limit may be too low.

  • HELOC / secured mortgage refinance

    • Pros: Lower interest rates; large borrowing capacity.

    • Cons: Secures debt with your home — risk of foreclosure if you default.

  • Consumer proposal (through Licensed Insolvency Trustee)

    • Pros: Legally binding reduction of debt and manageable payments.

    • Cons: Affects credit rating and remains on your credit report for years.

  • Credit counselling / debt management plan

    • Pros: Negotiated lower rates, single monthly payment to counselling agency.

    • Cons: Accounts may need to be closed; fees to counselling agency may apply.


Is consolidating credit card debt right for you?

Checklist — consider consolidating if:

  • You're juggling multiple high-interest credit cards or small loans.

  • A consolidation option offers a significantly lower annual interest rate.

  • You can commit to a realistic repayment plan and avoid new debt.

  • You have steady income and can handle any fees or setup costs.

Avoid consolidation if:

  • The new loan extends payments so long that you pay more interest overall.

  • The consolidation requires securing debt with your home and you can't handle the risk.

  • You're unable to change spending habits — consolidation can simply free up credit to be used again.


Step-by-step: How to consolidate debt in Canada

  1. List all debts. Include balances, interest rates, minimum payments, and any penalties for early payoff.

  2. Check your credit score. Get your free report from Equifax or TransUnion to understand what rates you'll qualify for.

  3. Compare options. Get quotes for personal loans, balance transfer cards, HELOCs, and credit counselling plans.

  4. Calculate all-in costs. Include interest, balance transfer or origination fees, legal fees (for proposals), and any prepayment penalties.

  5. Evaluate secured vs unsecured risk. Never secure consumer debt with your home unless you fully understand the implications.

  6. Apply for the best option. Read agreements carefully; watch for variable rates and promotional expiry dates.

  7. Stick to a repayment plan. Close or freeze paid-off accounts, and keep an emergency fund to avoid reusing credit.


How to calculate potential savings

  • Simple method: Compare monthly liabilities now versus consolidated payment and multiply by months to remaining term.

  • Include fees: Add any one-time fees (e.g., balance transfer fee) to the total consolidated cost.

  • Watch the timeline: A lower monthly payment may mean a longer term and more total interest.

Example: Two credit cards — $6,000 at 19.99% and $4,000 at 22.99% — consolidated to a $10,000 personal loan at 9% over 3 years generally saves significant interest versus minimum payments, but a 7-year loan at 9% could cost more overall despite lower monthly payments.


Risks and red flags

  • Secured consolidation puts your home at risk.

  • Introductory rates expire — always plan for the rate after the promo period.

  • Longer term = more interest even if monthly payments are smaller.

  • Fees can eliminate savings — read the fine print for origination or balance transfer fees.

  • Predatory lenders — watch out for high-cost loans and pressure tactics.


Canadian legal and support resources

  • FCAC guidance: For consumer-focused information on consolidating debt and budgeting, see the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada's advice on debt solutions.

  • Licensed Insolvency Trustees / bankruptcy: For formal insolvency options, consult the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada or search for a Licensed Insolvency Trustee.

  • Credit counselling: Look for not-for-profit counselling agencies affiliated with recognized associations (e.g., Canadian Association of Credit Counselling Services).

  • Credit reports: Order your free credit report from TransUnion or Equifax Canada to check errors and your score.


Alternatives to consolidation

  • Debt management plan through a credit counsellor — negotiate lower interest and a single payment.

  • Consumer proposal — a legal negotiated settlement with creditors via a Licensed Insolvency Trustee.

  • Negotiate directly with creditors — ask for interest relief or a payment plan.

  • Bankruptcy — last resort with long-term credit impacts.


Practical next steps

  1. Gather documents (statements, income proof, budget).

  2. Run the numbers (compare total cost and monthly payment).

  3. Seek free advice from FCAC resources or a non-profit credit counsellor before signing.

  4. Choose the safest option that helps you repay faster and protects essential assets like your home.

Final note: Debt consolidation can be a useful tool to manage money and reduce interest, but it's not a cure for ongoing overspending. If you're unsure, get independent, Canadian-regulated advice and verify terms before committing.